Horse Racing

Controversial photo finish sparks punter fury as judge is questioned after changing result of race

PUNTERS erupted in anger over a controversial photo finish – as the judge was questioned after changing the result of the race.

One horse was declared the winner only for the outcome to be changed to a dead-heat moments later.

Controversy surrounded this photo finish as one horse was declared the winner before the judge changed the result to a dead-heat

Proclaimer, the 2-1 favourite ridden by Richard Kingscote, and 13-2 Coverham under Theodore Ladd passed the post together in the 8.30 at Kempton on Tuesday night.

Nine lengths clear of third-placed Buckingham and too close to call with the naked eye, the call on who won went upstairs.

However it seemed even the judge couldn’t tell them apart – but only after deciding on two results.

First it was announced that the Julie Camacho-trained Proclaimer was the winner.

But then the official backtracked and said it was a dead-heat.

Racing TV host Rishi Persad described the ‘extraordinary’ scenes but admitted he had no idea what forced the change.

He said: “I’m not entirely certain of the circumstances that have unfolded that have led to this decision.”

Pundit Steve Mellish could only fold his arms and shake his head in disbelief.

Punters were a bit less diplomatic in voicing their opinion on what happened.

One said: “Madness. Absolute madness!”

Another commented: “Another howler. Stewarding needs a complete overhaul in this country.”

A fellow Twitter user wrote: “This is really unbelievable. Amount of times this has happened is very very worrying.”

One posted: “F***ing shocking.”


Another punter said: “Utter shambles again!”

One comment read: “Same happened at Perth last month. I think the judges need some new glasses.”

But another said the judge should be applauded for showing ‘courage’ in altering the outcome of the race.

The official stewards’ report on the BHA website read: “An enquiry was held into the circumstances surrounding the correction of the provisional placings in Race 8, from Proclaimer, as the winner, and Coverham, placed second, to be confirmed as a dead-heat.

“The Judge and the BHA Steward were interviewed. Having heard their evidence, a report was forwarded to the Head Office of the British Horseracing Authority for further consideration.”

At least there was some good news to come of it all, with Paddy Power announcing: “We’ve paid out, in full, on both Proclaimer and Coverham in the 8.30 Kempton as a goodwill gesture to our customers.”


Commercial content notice: Taking one of the bookmaker offers featured in this article may result in a payment to SE. 18+. T&Cs apply. Begambleaware.org

Remember to gamble responsibly

A responsible gambler is someone who:

  • Establishes time and monetary limits before playing
  • Only gambles with money they can afford to lose
  • Never chases their losses
  • Doesn’t gamble if they’re upset, angry or depressed
  • Gamcare – www.gamcare.org.uk
  • Gamble Aware – www.begambleaware.org

Did you miss our previous article…

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Popular

To Top